Archives for: April 2009


Permalink 12:59:29 pm, by fumanchu Email , 407 words   English (US)
Categories: IT, Python

Python is not PHP

I cringe at a lot of API's these days, because I see designers making the same mistakes again and again. Perhaps the most pervasive mistake is the dreaded NBU design: Namespacing By Underscores. For example, imagine you have a "Thing" class with a "color" attribute:

t = Thing()
t.color = 'red'

One day, you decide to switch from color names to RGB triples. Why, oh, why is this your first thought?

t.color_r = 255
t.color_g = 0
t.color_b = 0

That's your PHP (or Javascript, or SQL, or other) experience poking its ugly head in. Yes, PHP 5.3 finally has namespaces, and you can use objects as namespaces in JS if you're diligent. But chances are, you won't.

In Python, namespaces are easy. Use them. Ask yourself what the clearest syntax is, and you might come up with something like this:

>>> t.color = RGB(255, 0, 0)

This is not just a matter of clever delegation (replacing a str attribute with an RGB object)--it covers all manner of interface design decisions. Here's a recent example from python-dev regarding the email package's interface for Python 3:


Please don't do that--it makes it seem as if the "message" object has a set of headers and a distinct set of bytes_headers. At the least, you've elevated the rare case to be a peer of the common case. A new user of the email module shouldn't see anything about bytes in help(message) or dir(message). Instead, write this:

message.headers['Subject'] = 'A conversation'
message.headers['Subject'].encoding = 'utf-8'

Or, if you really prefer bytes over unicode as the canonical representation:

message.headers['Subject'] = b'A conversation'
message.headers['Subject'].encoding = 'utf-8'

If message.headers[x].encoding is given a sane default, and you expect the vast majority of users to only deal in unicode, they may never see the .encoding and .encode attributes. Good! We've made the common case easy and the rare cases possible.

In addition, we've embellished the Header object with a bytes representation using standard Python conventions: just like Python 3's str object has an encode method, so does our Header object. It's far easier to remember that such a convention applies, than to remember a brand-new name like "bytes_headers" or "decoded_headers".

Namespaces are one honking great idea -- let's do more of those! But please not faked via underscores.


Permalink 10:06:00 am, by fumanchu Email , 132 words   English (US)
Categories: IT, Python, Dejavu, CherryPy

PyCon Presentations

For PyCon 2009, I'm giving two talks! One on extending CherryPy and one on the innards of Dejavu/GeniuSQL. I think I've finally reduced my talks to the required time slots (I could easily have made 4-hour talks for each ;) and posted my presentations:

Use the arrow keys or mouse-click to proceed through them. The images don't load as fast over the network as they will when I present, so be patient if you preview them yourself. Also, try to use 1024 x 768 fullscreen--they're laid out specifically for that resolution.

Update: video is now available thanks to the great people who put on PyCon:

April 2009
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << < Current> >>
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30    


The requested Blog doesn't exist any more!

XML Feeds

powered by b2evolution